Skip to content
Independent reporting

Western Journal says Mullin dressed down Rep. Thanedar—but one big detail doesn’t add up

Share X Facebook Email

Claim vs. reality: The Western Journal published a piece asserting that Sen. Markwayne Mullin engaged in a tense back-and-forth with Rep. Shri Thanedar during a House Homeland Security Committee hearing. The article alleges that Thanedar arrived late, asked previously answered questions, and had faced a prior animal-cruelty accusation.

What the outlet says: According to the piece, Mullin “repeatedly humiliated” Thanedar in the exchange. It also says Thanedar had lost a primary earlier this year and characterizes his questioning as redundant. These are the outlet’s assertions; the article cites a video clip of the hearing.

Immediate red flag: The story refers to Markwayne Mullin as “Homeland Security Secretary.” That title is incorrect; Mullin is a U.S. senator. This mislabeling calls for extra caution and independent verification before drawing conclusions about the exchange or its context.

What we can and can’t verify from the article alone:

  • We have not independently reviewed the full hearing video or transcript.
  • The claims about Thanedar’s arrival time, questioning, and a past animal-cruelty accusation are presented by the Western Journal; they are not independently confirmed here.
  • The committee venue is described as the House Homeland Security Committee by the outlet; that, too, requires confirmation.

Bottom line: The Western Journal asserts a heated Mullin–Thanedar clash at a Homeland Security hearing, but its misidentification of Mullin’s job is a significant accuracy issue. Until the underlying video and official records are reviewed, treat the outlet’s characterizations and allegations as unverified.

Share X Facebook Email

The 2024 Brief

The day’s essential headlines, without the noise.

A concise briefing delivered directly to your inbox.

Free to join. Unsubscribe any time.

Powered by Reach Response